Site MapSubscribe Contact UsHome

Put Investors in Their Place

By Scott D. Anthony, Clayton M. Christensen

Why pander to people who now hold shares, on average, less than 10 months?

Why do smart, motivated, hardworking managers find it so difficult to innovate? Here's one key culprit: the belief that management's primary obligation is to maximize shareholder value. That credo, which is shaky to begin with, distorts managers' sense of responsibility. And in fact it has been rendered obsolete by developments in the capital markets.

The notion that managers must above all appease investors drives behavior that focuses exclusively on quarterly results. Thus, many management teams hesitate to invest in promising innovations that are likely to hurt near-term financial performance. As a consequence, leaders in industries facing disruptive change—such as grocery retailing and newspapers—lose both direction and strength as they try to figure out what kind of shareholder value they should create.

How did managers develop this risky fixation? It turns out the entreaty to maximize investor value was not revealed by a deity to any of the prophets of profit. It came from economists. Calculus is a primary analytical tool of microeconomics. The essence of calculus is maximization and minimization. At some point, some now-defunct economist seems to have said: "Let us assume that managers' responsibility is to maximize shareholder value." This made the mathematics work. And through endless repetition, nearly everyone came to assume that managers are responsible for maximizing shareholder value.

Through the 1960s, this premise wasn't at odds with reality: The average shareholding period was more than five years. Managers seeking to maximize the long-term strength and growth of their companies could reward these patient shareholders. But today shares are held, on average, less than 10 months. Should managers really regard such investors, whose investment horizons are shorter than the most nearsighted of managers, as stakeholders whose value they ought to maximize?

Perhaps it is time for companies to adjust the paradigm of management responsibility: "You are investors and speculators, not shareholders, and you temporarily find yourselves holding the securities of our company. You are responsible for maximizing the returns on your investments. Our responsibility is to maximize the long-term value of this company. We will therefore act in the interest of those whose interests coincide with our long-term prospects, namely employees, customers, the communities in which our employees live, and the minority of investors who plan to hold our securities for several years."

Companies that are serious about serving patient capital might even consider changing how they are organized. Certain outfits that have demonstrated the ability to take advantage of disruptive change have a different ownership structure from most public companies in the U.S. and Europe. Tata Sons in India, for example, is a privately held conglomerate. It has expanded into luxury hotels, information-technology services, and online education and entertainment. Certain of Tata Sons' subsidiaries are publicly held, while others are private. This seems to give it the luxury of creating, under the private umbrella, new business units whose economic models are disruptive to the parents' model.

Read the full article on Bloomberg BusinessWeek

Related Insights

Innosight in Harvard Business Review:

The New M&A Playbook

Read more

An Impact Story from Innosight:

ChotuKool – how can you improve the lives of millions in an emerging market?

Read more

The idea to address the basic daily cooling needs at an affordable cost was born from the disruptive innovation workshop led by Clayton Christensen through Innosight. The larger vision behind the ChotuKool initiative was to make the lives of the people at the bottom of the pyramid brighter.

G Sunderraman
Vice President, Godrej & Boyce

Grow with Innosight

Interested in learning how Innosight can help your organization?

Contact us

Meet our team and explore what it's like to work at Innosight.